National Anthems: Home | Africa | Americas | Asia | Australia&Oceania | Europe | Olympic Anthem |

 
Passports: Home [ Africa ] [ Americas, Australia & Oceania] [ Asia] [ Europe] [ Other documents
Travel:
[Europe] [ Asia ] [ USA-Canada ] [ Latin-America ] [ Africa ] [ Australia ] [ Carabben ] [ Air ] [Cruises ]
Forum
Live chat




Subject: Re: The role played by non-Europeans in the Great War Posted on: Fri, 02 May 2008 09:11:32 GMT

nightjar
> A nice sound-bite, but even if were true, you wouldn't get people doing that
> without a lot of training in good discipline. I have a military training
> manual from 1941 and, apart from the sections on tank hunting and the Bren
> gun, it wouldn't have been much different from those in use in the Great
> War. It is about A5 size and 1/2 inch thick, set in close type. Even digging
> a trench has to be done in a specific order, with the spoil being built
> carefully into a pa.t and a parados.
>
> Colin Bignell

Sorry, I used to work at the Army Staff College and if you think there was any
parity in training or tactics between the first and the second, you are in
need of some lessons in history.
The Aussies suffered 64% casualties, with 60k killed, the French 75% and
nearly ten million killed in a very short range series of conflicts.

Many of the troops in the last two years had less than three weeks training
and the idea of well trained troops came out of the war.

JJ

1022714. Re: Ferry Scotland - Bergen 1022714
1022715. Travel to Portugal Video 1022715
1022716. Travel to Portugal Video 1022716
1022717. Re: Ferry Scotland - Bergen 1022717
1022718. Re: Frugal living in Paris, France 1022718
1022719. Re: Ferry Scotland - Bergen 1022719
1022720. Re: Frugal living in Paris, France 1022720
1022721. Re: Yikes! Gas Price $5 Gallon in Canada - Don't Visit Alberta!! Or C
1022722. Re: Value of the dollar 1022722
1022723. Re: Frugal living in Paris, France 1022723
1022724. Re: A train from Vienna to Sophia? 1022724
1022725. Re: Frugal living in Paris, France 1022725
1022726. Re: Germans can't face their own past and move on 1022726
1022727. Re: Frugal living in Paris, France 1022727
1022728. Re: Germans can't face their own past and move on 1022728
1022729. London theatre, Italian opera 1022729
1022730. Re: London theatre, Italian opera 1022730
1022731. Re: Germans can't face their own past and move on 1022731
1022732. Re: Frugal living in Paris, France 1022732
1022733. Re: Frugal living in Paris, France 1022733